Master's Thesis

Methods of Enhancement of PGPR Viability and Persistence in Biochar Carriers

Final Thesis 3.3 MB

Author of thesis: Jana Meyer zu Hörste

Acad. year: 2026/2027

Supervisor: Ing. Michal Kalina, Ph.D.

Reviewer: doc. Ing. Petr Sedláček, Ph.D.

Abstract:

Biofertilizers are a way to contribute to sustainable agriculture. The main challenge of biofertilizer products is maintaining the bacterial viability in the finished product, considering also economic aspects. To identify a suitable formulation for a potential biofertilizer based on Azotobacter vinelandii, this thesis investigated the viability effects on bacterial cells encapsulated in either a plain hydrogel carrier (“hydrogel”), a lignohumate-supplemented hydrogel carrier (LH hydrogel”), an encapsulated biochar carrier (“biochar”) and a lignohumate-supplemented encapsulated biochar carrier (“LH biochar”). A carrier based on chia seed mucilage was compared with the alginate hydrogel-based carrier without success in gelation. The different carriers were lyophilized with various cryoprotectants, mainly trehalose, sorbitol, lignohumate and a mix and their viability was assessed before and after lyophilization by flow cytometry. The viscoelastic properties of the carriers were assessed through rheology and the retained functionality and ability to grow cultures of the lyophilized samples was assessed through plate tests. In comparison to the plain hydrogel carrier without cryoprotectants, the biochar carrier and LH hydrogel carrier showed significantly better viability after freeze-drying, while no cryoprotectants were shown to have a statistically significant effect on viability. Gel strength was significantly higher in the LH biochar carrier. The ability to grow cultures was retained in all samples throughout lyophilization and plant growth-promoting abilities were shown to be retained for phosphate solubilization and nitrogen fixation, while siderophore production and production of ACC deaminase gave inconclusive results. Based on the findings, the formulation showing most promise for maintaining high bacterial viability is an encapsulated biochar carrier as well as sorbitol as cryoprotectant. Overall, this thesis built the foundation for identifying an effective inoculant formulation for Azotobacter vinelandii which contributes to the efforts of developing a commercial biofertilizer based on these results.

Keywords:

Azotobacter vinelandii, biofertilizer, bioinoculant, biochar, alginate, hydrogel, viability,
lyophilization, PGPR

Date of defence

30.09.2026

Result of the defence

Defended (thesis was successfully defended)

znamkaAznamka

Grading

A

Process of defence

The student presented her thesis, its content and results. Afterwards, the supervisor's and opponent's opinions were read and questions were answered. Other members of the committee joined the discussion with the following questions. Assoc. Prof. P. Diviš: How did you statistically analyze the experiments? What does it mean that you did not find statistically significant differences? What kind of compounds in biochar can be dangerous to organisms? Assoc. Prof. H. Zlámalová Gargošová: What was the origin of the biochar you used? Can biochar affect bacterial viability? Dr. J. Másilko: What is lyophilization used for, and what is the mechanism of the process? The student answered all the additional questions of the members of the Commission that were raised during the discussion on the issue. In the discussion the student demonstrated excellent orientation in the given issue. The discussion was followed by the evaluation of the thesis. The student demonstrated not only excellent professional knowledge but also the ability to independently present her results.

Language of thesis

English

Faculty

Department

Study programme

Environmental Sciences and Engineering (NPAP_ENVI)

Composition of Committee

doc. Mgr. Renata Komendová, Ph.D. (člen)
doc. MVDr. Helena Zlámalová Gargošová, Ph.D. (člen)
prof. Ing. Jozef Krajčovič, Ph.D. (předseda)
doc. Mgr. Michaela Vašinová Galiová, Ph.D. (člen)
doc. Ing. Pavel Diviš, Ph.D. (místopředseda)
prof. Ing. Tomáš Weidlich, Ph.D. (člen)
Ing. Jiří Másilko, Ph.D. (člen)

Supervisor’s report
Ing. Michal Kalina, Ph.D.

Jana Meyer zu Hörste focused her master ’s  thesis on ways to improve the viability of Azotobacter vinelandii cells in alginate hydrogel carriers containing biochar. She examined carrier properties and bacterial viability during freeze-drying and rehydration, and compared the effects of protective additives, including sorbitol, lignohumate and trehalose. This is a relevant topic for the development of microbial inoculants. The thesis combines the preparation of several carrier formulations with measurements of bacterial viability, gel properties, culturability and selected plant growth-promoting traits.
The experimental work required the student to coordinate a broad range of methods and respond to practical difficulties, including the need to replace an unsuitable batch of bacterial culture by a new one. Jana approached these tasks very independently, purposefully and responsibly. I also appreciate how well Jana adapted to the relatively unfamiliar laboratory environment at the Faculty of Chemistry, Brno University of Technology, where she spent approximately six months working on her master’s   thesis.  I particularly value how she planned and scheduled her work, evaluated results as they became available and adapted the experimental procedure where necessary. She obtained an interesting set of data showing, in particular, the potential of biochar-containing carriers to maintain bacterial viability after freeze-drying and subsequent rehydration. The statistical treatment deserves special recognition: she distinguished biological from technical replicates, selected appropriate methods for the different datasets and discussed the limitations imposed by unequal replication.
I have minor reservations about the presentation of some graphical results. Several figures would benefit from clearer visual organisation and more legible labels; there are also occasional typographical inconsistencies in the text. These issues do not substantially affect the scientific value of the work. The thesis also identifies questions that remain open, particularly the longer-term stability of the formulations and their performance in soil in the presence of plants.
In conclusion, Jana Meyer zu Hörste has provided a valuable basis for the further development of biochar-based bacterial inoculants and has demonstrated an excellent approach to independent experimental research. I recommend her master’s thesis for defence and propose the grade "excellent" (A).
Evaluation criteria Grade
Meeting the requirements of the thesis assignment A
Study of the literature and its processing A
Use of knowledge gained from the literature A
Quality of achieved results B
Interpretation and discussion of the results A
Conclusions of the thesis and their formulation A
Use of consultations in the process of writing A
Overall approach to solving assigned tasks A

Grade proposed by supervisor: A

The thesis addresses one of the key bottlenecks in the development of bacterial biofertilizers: keeping plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) viable during downstream processing, freeze-drying in particular. The author worked with Azotobacter vinelandii, a strain that produces its own alginate and can therefore be self-entrapped in a hydrogel matrix without externally supplied alginate. She compared four encapsulated carrier compositions (plain hydrogel, lignohumate-supplemented hydrogel, biochar-filled hydrogel and lignohumate-supplemented biochar-filled hydrogel) in combination with several cryoprotective additives. She evaluated the carriers’ viscoelastic properties, bacterial viability before and after lyophilization, metabolic activity, culturability and retention of selected plant growth-promoting traits, and additionally tested a chia seed mucilage-based carrier. Overall, I consider the thesis a high-quality, comprehensive and original piece of work.

The theoretical part and literature review are very well done. The author draws on an extensive body of literature (183 references), mostly relevant, recent, high-quality primary sources. The reference list has a few formal flaws. Several German bibliographic abbreviations and phrases remain from the citation manager (e.g. “Bd.”, “u. a.”, “abgerufen am”, “Hrsg.”). In reference [14], a key reference on which the thesis directly builds, the author list is truncated, and the corresponding author is missing as a result.

The number of typographical and formal errors is negligible, for example “liquid-cristalline” (p. 14) and several organism names not italicized (pp. 14 and 23). Factual errors are also few. The most notable are the incorrect expansion of the abbreviation ACC as “Acetyl-CoA carboxylase” (pp. 8 and 31; it should be 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate) and the description of the acetylene reduction assay (p. 17), where the detected product of nitrogenase activity is ethylene, not acetylene.

I particularly appreciate how systematically and clearly the literature review is organized, for example the overview of studies on protective additives in Table 1. All non-trivial terms and concepts are briefly explained. This makes the text easy to read and understand, even though the topic spans several disciplines: microbiology, soil science, polymer and colloid chemistry, rheology, and process engineering.

The experimental part follows clearly from the theoretical background. The author explicitly identifies gaps in current knowledge, derives research questions from them, and formulates testable hypotheses. The experiments are extensive and yield a large amount of original data. The thesis thus has substantial potential for application in the development of commercial bioinoculants, and its results also have direct publication potential.

Several aspects of the methodology are not described in enough detail, notably the gelation procedure, the origin of the lyophilization parameters, how samples were diluted for flow cytometry, and the method used to assess culturability. These points are raised among the questions for the defence below.

I commend the author’s effort to process the data statistically in a systematic way. She checked model assumptions, applied parametric or non-parametric tests as appropriate, used post-hoc comparisons with multiplicity correction, and made the R scripts publicly available. However, some statistical results are presented in a way that appears counterintuitive, mainly because of the unbalanced experimental design (see the question on Figure 8a below). I also value that the hypotheses are not evaluated merely by stating test outcomes. The author interprets the results in detail, discusses the methodological limitations behind inconclusive findings (e.g. possible false negatives in the CAS assay and false positives in the ACC deaminase assay for a diazotrophic strain), and proposes concrete modifications of the methodology for future work.

In conclusion, this is an excellent master’s thesis that clearly exceeds the requirements for this type of final thesis in all key respects. Its contribution to the field of study is indisputable. The main objectives defined in the thesis assignment have been fulfilled to a large extent (the optimization of drying protocol is missing). I recommend the thesis for defence and grade it “Excellent (A)”.
Evaluation criteria Grade
Meeting the requirements of the thesis assignment B
Logical structure of the thesis A
Quality of the achieved results A
Interpretation and discussion of the results A
Use of literature and citations A
Level of the language used A
Formal level of thesis and overall impression A
Conclusions of the thesis and their formulation A
Topics for thesis defence:
  1. Gelation procedure. Compared with the original protocol in reference [14], which your work builds on, a considerably lower amount of the crosslinking agent (Ca²⁺) was used relative to the volume of the bacterial culture (5 ml of 2 % CaCl₂ per 20 ml of culture). What was the reason for this change? Could an insufficient amount of crosslinker also explain the relatively low and poorly reproducible mechanical properties of the plain hydrogels, i.e. the low plateau storage modulus and its high standard deviation (1481 ± 1834 Pa, Table 9)?
  2. Freeze-drying parameters. One of the objectives in the thesis assignment was to optimize the processing and drying procedures for the colonized carriers. Where do the lyophilization parameters in Table 2 come from? Are they the result of your own optimization, or were they adopted from the literature or an established laboratory protocol? If adopted, what was done to address the optimization objective?
  3. Dilution for flow cytometry. Section 5.6.2 states that samples were diluted to a target concentration of 10^5–10^6 cells per µl. How was this dilution set, or “calibrated”? Was it based on optical density, on a preliminary cytometric count, or on an empirical dilution factor? Were absolute cell counts recorded by FC, or only the ratio of live to dead events?
  4. Culturability assessment. Culturability was assessed as the percentage of plate area covered by growth after streaking. The inoculation procedure is not described (inoculum volume and cell concentration, streaking technique, whether the plate quadrants represented successive dilutions or not). Streaking is essentially a qualitative isolation technique. The covered area depends strongly on operator technique, colony size and incubation time, and it saturates at very low cell numbers (as the ~100 % coverage of all fresh cultures shows). Moreover, the inoculum was not normalized to cell number. How do these limitations affect the conclusions drawn from Figure 15, in particular the conclusion that no sample entered the VBNC state? Can you propose a more suitable quantitative culturability assay?
  5. pH adjustment. What pH changes did the addition of lignohumate and biochar cause in the cultivation medium, and how much sulfuric acid had to be added to bring the pH to about 7? Could this pH shift, and possibly the higher sulfate load, contribute to the markedly lower fresh viability of the LH hydrogel culture (36.3 %, Table 8)?
  6. Statistical evaluation of carrier effects (Figure 8a). In Figure 8a, the biochar carrier differs significantly from the plain hydrogel (p.adj = 0.026), whereas the LH biochar carrier does not (p.adj = 0.076), although its mean viability is higher and its error bars are considerably smaller. Please explain this apparent discrepancy. What exactly do the bars and error bars in Figure 8a represent, and how do they relate to the estimates and standard errors in Table A4 on which the significance letters are based? What role does the unbalanced experimental design play (i.e. which additives and how many replicates were available for each carrier)? Would you recommend a different statistical approach, or at least a way of presenting the results that makes the significance letters consistent with what the figure shows?
  7. Secondary benefits of the carrier components. You evaluate the addition of biochar and lignohumate mainly with respect to the primary purpose of the bioinoculant, i.e. the viability of the encapsulated PGPR. Could you discuss whether their secondary effects on soil and plants would also favour including them in the developed products, for example biochar as a soil conditioner that improves water retention, cation exchange capacity and carbon sequestration, and lignohumate as a plant biostimulant? Could these benefits justify their use even where the effect on bacterial viability is not statistically significant?

Grade proposed by reviewer: A

Responsibility: Mgr. et Mgr. Hana Odstrčilová