Master's Thesis

Tailor-made MOF ligands for sustainable energy conversion

Author of thesis: Azrin Nazir

Acad. year: 2026/2027

Supervisor: Ing. Lucia Ivanová, Ph.D.

Reviewer: Mgr. Jan Richtár, Ph.D.

Abstract:

Metal organic frameworks (MOF) are an option for photocatalytic hydrogen evolution reactions (HER) with the aim of producing green hydrogen. However, research is ongoing to search for metal centres and organic ligands to synthesize MOFs that can achieve high hydrogen yields. Curcumin resembles other previously studied MOF ligands and has properties that may make it suitable for use as a MOF ligand. Furthermore, there is limited research conducted on using curcumin- and curcuminoid derivatives as MOF ligands for the purpose of HER. Three target compounds were identified based on literature research and initial recommendations from research collaborators and further supported with computational characterization. This theoretical computation was used to predict the properties of these target compounds as well as to gain initial insights on the compounds’ possible geometry and viability for MOF synthesis. Synthetic pathways were formulated and optimized by adapting reaction conditions documented in previous studies to synthesize the target compounds at sufficient yields by adapting reaction conditions documented in previous studies to synthesize the target compounds at sufficient yields ranging from 20 to 60% for the target compounds. The protection of reactive catechol moieties in the starting materials used was required for successful synthesis of two of the three target compounds. One of the target compounds, demethylated curcumin, was further analysed through optical and electrochemical characterization. This research has confirmed that curcumin- and curcuminoid derivatives display properties that make it potentially usable as MOF ligands. Future research is required to synthesize MOFs using the target compounds and conduct pilot HER experiments.

Keywords:

Metal organic framework, Ligands, Organic synthesis, Hydrogen evolution reaction, Curcumin derivatives, Curcuminoid derivatives

Date of defence

30.09.2026

Date of publish

29.09.2031

Result of the defence

Defended (thesis was successfully defended)

znamkaAznamka

Grading

A

Process of defence

The student presented his thesis and summarized its main content and results. The supervisor's and opponent's reports were subsequently read, and the student answered the questions raised in them. Additional questions were asked by the members of the examination committee: Assoc. Prof. H. Zlámalová Gargošová” How “green” is the preparation of this compound? Prof. T. Weidlich: Is it possible to estimate why the yield of the aldol reaction was relatively low? Dr. J. Másilko: What type of X-ray diffraction method did you use? How did you prepare the sample? Is it difficult to prepare this type of sample? The student addressed all supplementary questions posed by the members of the Commission during the discussion. He demonstrated an excellent understanding of the topic and a strong orientation within the subject matter. Following the discussion, the thesis was evaluated. The student proved not only outstanding professional knowledge but also the capability to independently present and defend his results.

Language of thesis

English

Faculty

Department

Study programme

Environmental Sciences and Engineering (NPAP_ENVI)

Composition of Committee

doc. Mgr. Renata Komendová, Ph.D. (člen)
doc. MVDr. Helena Zlámalová Gargošová, Ph.D. (člen)
prof. Ing. Jozef Krajčovič, Ph.D. (předseda)
doc. Mgr. Michaela Vašinová Galiová, Ph.D. (člen)
doc. Ing. Pavel Diviš, Ph.D. (místopředseda)
prof. Ing. Tomáš Weidlich, Ph.D. (člen)
Ing. Jiří Másilko, Ph.D. (člen)

Supervisor’s report
Ing. Lucia Ivanová, Ph.D.

Azrin Nazir’s master’s thesis, Tailor–made MOF ligands for sustainable energy conversion, focuses on the design, synthesis, and characterization of nature-inspired organic ligands intended for the development of metal–organic frameworks for photocatalytic applications. The student prepared a comprehensive literature review drawing on 234 scientific sources and effectively applied the knowledge gained to his experimental work.
Throughout the project, Azrin demonstrated a responsible, diligent, and proactive approach. He quickly became independent in the laboratory, worked carefully, and showed excellent time management. He was eager to acquire new skills and contributed his own ideas to the development of synthetic procedures. When reactions were unsuccessful, he thoroughly investigated relevant literature to identify possible causes and explore alternative approaches. He communicated reliably and made effective use of consultations. He was consistently punctual, met all agreed deadlines, and discussed questions and uncertainties constructively.
The experimental work was conducted during his two semesters at the Faculty of Chemistry, Brno University of Technology, within the double-degree programme. Despite having substantially less time for laboratory work at FCH than students following the standard two-year programme, he successfully managed demanding synthetic work and prepared three target ligands. Computational studies and electrochemical measurements were carried out with the assistance of Dr. Jan Truksa, with the student’s contribution focused primarily on data processing and interpretation. Detailed optical and electrochemical characterization was performed for one target compound; the other two were successfully synthesized towards the end of the experimental period.
The thesis was written independently and progressively, and the text required no substantial revisions. The student carefully considered and incorporated feedback, seeking clarification whenever necessary. The principal contribution of the work is the synthesis of new nature-inspired MOF ligands, which will be further investigated for MOF preparation in collaboration with TU Wien.
In my assessment, the main objectives of the thesis have been achieved. The work demonstrates the student’s ability to apply scientific knowledge to a demanding experimental project and provides a valuable basis for further research. I recommend the thesis for defence and propose the grade A.
Evaluation criteria Grade
Meeting the requirements of the thesis assignment A
Study of the literature and its processing A
Use of knowledge gained from the literature A
Quality of achieved results A
Interpretation and discussion of the results A
Conclusions of the thesis and their formulation A
Use of consultations in the process of writing A
Overall approach to solving assigned tasks A

Grade proposed by supervisor: A

Reviewer’s report
Mgr. Jan Richtár, Ph.D.

This master’s thesis investigates curcumin and curcuminoid derivatives as potential ligands for metal–organic frameworks intended for photocatalytic hydrogen evolution. The topic is scientifically relevant and contributes to research on materials for solar energy conversion. The main contribution lies in developing synthetic routes and addressing practical challenges in preparing and isolating the selected compounds.

I appreciate the extensive literature review, the rationale for selecting the target structures, and the comparison of alternative synthetic approaches. The protection of catechol groups as tetrahydropyranyl ethers, followed by deprotection, is particularly valuable. The discussion of unsuccessful experiments, stability issues, and opportunities for further optimization is also useful. The DFT and TD-DFT calculations provided through collaboration complement the experimental work.

On the other hand, I would expand the structural characterization of target compound [5], whose identification relies mainly on FTIR. The author states that the sample for NMR analysis was not sufficiently concentrated; however, the NMR acquisition parameters could have been optimized to address this problem. Moreover, since the compound was purified by column chromatography, reporting its Rf value could have been beneficial. I would also be rather careful when reporting experimental and calculated values, as the number of significant figures is not always consistent with the precision of the measurements or the subsequent calculations. The experimental section also contains an inconsistency between the yield of compound [10] expressed as a mass and as a percentage (p. 46). Furthermore, the ¹³C NMR spectra provided in the appendices would benefit from phase correction.

In the Results and Discussion section, I would be more careful when reporting the narrowing of the optical gap of compound [2] by 0.011–0.020 eV relative to curcumin, given the overlapping confidence intervals of the optical band gaps determined using the Tauc method (Table 6).

In the section on electrochemical characterization, I would provide more experimental information, particularly regarding the concentrations, the supporting electrolyte, and the scan rate. The text and figure caption also identify different solvents (acetonitrile and chloroform). The HOMO estimate uses the oxidation peak maximum rather than the oxidation onset, which may influence the calculated value.

Despite these reservations, the thesis demonstrates an ability to address synthetic problems and provides very useful groundwork for further research. The synthetic objectives have largely been achieved, while conclusions regarding applications and future research goals are stated clearly. I recommend the thesis for defence and propose a grade of B.
Evaluation criteria Grade
Meeting the requirements of the thesis assignment B
Logical structure of the thesis A
Quality of the achieved results B
Interpretation and discussion of the results B
Use of literature and citations A
Level of the language used A
Formal level of thesis and overall impression B
Conclusions of the thesis and their formulation B
Topics for thesis defence:
  1. What further experiments would you propose to assess whether the prepared ligands can be used to construct MOFs suitable for photocatalytic hydrogen evolution?
  2. The studied derivatives generally bear two hydroxyl groups on each aromatic ring. Could analogous compounds bearing three hydroxyl groups per ring, such as gallic acid derivatives, also be promising candidates for further investigation?
  3. Which experimental methods could be used to determine the three-dimensional molecular structure of the studied derivatives and thereby verify the computational predictions? In case of 1,3-dicarbonyl compounds, geometry could considerably differ for their keto-enol tautomers. Could author comment on a tendency of the corresponding derivatives to tautomerize?
Points proposed by reviewer: 85

Grade proposed by reviewer: B

Reasons for publication postponement

The postponement of publication in order to protect results that are not yet published in accordance with the provision of § 47b, paragraph 4 of Act No. 111/1998 Coll., on Higher Education Institutions.

Responsibility: Mgr. et Mgr. Hana Odstrčilová